Explainer

D-Wave vs Quip Network: how they compare

Quip Network
Postquant Labs
·3 min read

D-Wave sells time on its Advantage2 annealers through its Leap cloud service. Quip Network posts each QUBO as a job with a reward attached, and miners on CPUs, GPUs and quantum annealers compete to solve it while the chain checks every answer.

A quick comparison

D-Wave builds quantum annealers, machines designed for optimization problems, and sells access through Leap or installs them on site. D-Wave says more than 100 organizations use its systems and services.

Quip Network, built by Postquant Labs, is a decentralized marketplace for quantum computing. It doesn't build quantum computers. Its first quantum subnet uses D-Wave annealers among the machines that answer jobs on Quip Network.

Who does the work. On Leap, D-Wave's own QPUs and hybrid solvers solve problems. On Quip Network, miners on mixed hardware compete for each job, unless you limit it to certain miners or hardware types.

Access and price. Leap's sign-up trial runs demos only. Solver access takes an approved trial or a paid contract, with no public per-use rate. Quip Network allows anyone to submit and set a reward per job, paid to the winning miners.

Checking answers. Leap returns samples and their energies. Quip's chain recomputes every answer's energy and enforces the quality floors you set.

Maturity. D-Wave is in production and states 99.9% availability. Quip Network is on testnet, with mainnet coming after an external audit of its chain code.

What an optimization problem is

An optimization problem asks for the best choice out of a huge number of options, such as the order of a truck's stops or the assets a portfolio holds. The options multiply fast. For a 23-stop route, a computer checking a billion routes a second would need about 18,000 years to try them all.

Annealers take these problems as a QUBO (quadratic unconstrained binary optimization). Each variable is a yes-or-no choice, 0 or 1, and each choice and each pair of choices adds to a total cost. The solver looks for the assignment with the lowest total. Written with spins of minus one and plus one instead, the same problem is an Ising model, the form Quip Network’s miners solve.

The two side by side

D-Wave Leap Quip Network
Who solves the job D-Wave's Advantage and Advantage2 QPUs, plus D-Wave's hybrid solvers. Competing miners on CPU, GPU and quantum annealing hardware.
Hardware Advantage2: 4,400+ qubits, 40,000+ couplers, 20 couplers per qubit. Whatever miners declare; a job can be limited to named miners or hardware types. Quip Network supports D-Wave systems now, with additional hardware support to follow.
Price Contract pricing, with no public per-use rate. You set a reward per job, paid to the winning miners.
Answer checking Returns samples and energies; no certificate described. The chain recomputes every answer's energy and enforces your quality floors.
Status In production, with 99.9% availability stated. Testnet; mainnet follows an external chain audit.

Running a QUBO on Quip Network

Quip Network's XQuad toolchain takes one model and sends it to a local CPU solver or the Quip Network, where miners on CPUs, GPUs and quantum annealers compete to solve it. The chain pays the answers ranked best under the payout rule you chose when posting. QVM, the Quip Virtual Machine that runs XQuad programs on the network, supports D-Wave systems alongside classical hardware, with IonQ support to follow.

The same QUBO works on both. On D-Wave, the Ocean SDK stores it as a binary quadratic model for its samplers and QPUs. On Quip Network, XQuad converts it to an Ising model and encodes each coefficient as a whole number of thousandths, so every machine computes the same energy for the same answer.

D-Wave hardware already runs jobs on Quip Network. At Quantum.Tech World, a D-Wave Advantage QPU raced simulated annealing on 1,930 portfolio problems built by booth visitors, with every race run as a job on Quip Network. The QPU's portfolio was at least as good in all 1,930.

For other QUBO solvers on AWS and Azure, read QUBO solver marketplaces compared.

Try Quip Network

Follow our “Submit your first compute job” guide to post a QUBO to the Aglais testnet with free AGLS from the faucet.

Share
Filed underExplainer
Newsletter

Don't miss an update

Get new posts and project updates delivered to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.